A battle for the title of The Greatest Detective
4 posters
Blargaria :: OTHER :: Random Talk
Page 1 of 1
A battle for the title of The Greatest Detective
Who is the greatest Detective? Who can beat who in a battle of wits with no aid from a friend (examples: Watson or Robin), computer, or other outside source? It can be any one version or the collective knowledge of all of them of the said character (there is multiple versions of Sherlock and Batman)
Put in your reasoning WHY your vote would win.
I'm putting my money on the original great detective: Sherlock Holmes
I say him because the other 3 of these guys were basing their styles off of him. He was experimenting with advanced forensics before the idea was ever conceived. He knew almost everything about you just by shaking your hand or looking at your hat or shoes. (no magnifying glass needed) The modern versions has more up to date knowledge putting him back above today's greatest crime-fighting minds.
Put in your reasoning WHY your vote would win.
I'm putting my money on the original great detective: Sherlock Holmes
I say him because the other 3 of these guys were basing their styles off of him. He was experimenting with advanced forensics before the idea was ever conceived. He knew almost everything about you just by shaking your hand or looking at your hat or shoes. (no magnifying glass needed) The modern versions has more up to date knowledge putting him back above today's greatest crime-fighting minds.
Re: A battle for the title of The Greatest Detective
My vote is for Conan, but I got to give props to Sherlock, since he was able to do the same work without all the fancy technology Conan has.
Poirot doesn't even come close to these two.
Poirot doesn't even come close to these two.
Guest- Guest
Re: A battle for the title of The Greatest Detective
Batman of course -_- ... he has a world with fantasy creatures superpowered psycho's aliens and a superman to deal with.
yup if he investigates he finds the answer ... and best reason why is well ...
He is batman
yup if he investigates he finds the answer ... and best reason why is well ...
He is batman
boundbyluck- LEVEL 13
- Posts : 285
Age : 38
Location : somewhere
Re: A battle for the title of The Greatest Detective
boundbyluck wrote:Batman of course -_- ... he has a world with fantasy creatures superpowered psycho's aliens and a superman to deal with.
yup if he investigates he finds the answer ... and best reason why is well ...
He is batman
the votes dictate otherwise, my friend XD
Re: A battle for the title of The Greatest Detective
What? Any fans for professor Layton?...*sighs*
Guest- Guest
Re: A battle for the title of The Greatest Detective
Voca-Chan39 wrote:What? Any fans for professor Layton?...*sighs*
You could have voted for other, Voca
Re: A battle for the title of The Greatest Detective
Voca-Chan39 wrote:What? Any fans for professor Layton?...*sighs*
Layton ain't a really a detective in my opinion... I he is, than I vote for PW has best detective :/
Guest- Guest
ScarHead- LEVEL 4
- Posts : 85
Age : 36
Location : Ontario, CA
Blargaria :: OTHER :: Random Talk
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|